Shure SM58 or SM57, which one works better for your voice at home?

Same capsule, different grille: the SM58 has a pop filter, the SM57 does not. What the specs say about each, which variant to buy, and how much preamp gain either needs on a Mac.


Two mics sit side by side on the Shure website, both $109, both with grey bodies, both cardioid dynamics with an XLR socket at the bottom. One is sold as a vocal microphone, the other as an instrument microphone. A forum thread tells you they share the same capsule, so you buy the SM57 because it looks more "studio", screw it onto a desk arm, and on your first call a colleague asks why every "p" sounds like someone tapping the mic. Nothing is broken. You bought the mic without the pop filter.

That is most of the answer. The rest is worth knowing before you spend money.

Short version: for a voice at home (calls, podcasts, streams, singing practice), the Shure SM58 is the safer pick. Pick the SM57 if you also want to record a guitar amp or a snare drum with the same mic, or if your voice reads as dull and you are willing to add a foam windscreen. Neither one plugs straight into a Mac: both need a preamp with plenty of gain, and that box matters more to your result than the choice between 57 and 58.

If you have not yet decided whether a dynamic mic is right for you at all, read whether a dynamic mic is really better for podcasting in a normal room first. This page assumes you already want a dynamic and are choosing between the two most famous ones.

Shure SM57 vs SM58: the same capsule behind a different grille

Shure's FAQ on this exact question, dated June 2026, says the two mics are based on the same cartridge design and that the main difference is the grille. The SM58 has the familiar ball grille with a pop filter built in. The SM57 has no ball and no pop filtering: its small grille is part of the cartridge assembly itself.

That one physical change moves the diaphragm. On the SM57 the distance from the top of the grille to the diaphragm is shorter, so at the same position of your mouth against the metal, the capsule is closer to you. Shure lists two consequences: a more pronounced proximity effect (bass that swells as you get close) and slightly higher output above 5 kHz.

Here is what the current Shure user guides list for each mic, as of October 2026:

SpecShure SM58Shure SM57
TypeDynamic (moving coil)Dynamic (moving coil)
PatternCardioidCardioid
Frequency response50 to 15,000 Hz40 to 15,000 Hz
Sensitivity-56.0 dBV/Pa (1.6 mV)-56.0 dBV/Pa (1.6 mV)
Impedance300 ohm310 ohm
Weight0.33 kg0.284 kg
Pop filterBuilt into the ball grilleNone (Shure sells the A2WS foam)
Price on shure.com US$109$109
In the boxA25D stand clip, bagA25D stand clip, bag

Two rows deserve attention. The sensitivity is identical, so the two mics need exactly the same amount of preamp gain; neither one is "easier" to drive. And the price is identical on Shure's US store, so you are not saving money by picking the instrument mic. Street prices drift, but the old idea that the SM57 is the cheaper of the two does not hold at Shure's own list price.

What the spec sheets say about the SM58 and SM57 for vocals

No spec sheet can tell you how a mic will suit your particular voice, and this page will not pretend to. What the documents do describe is where each mic adds or removes energy, and that predicts a lot.

Low end. Shure describes the SM58's response as "tailored for vocals, with brightened midrange and bass rolloff", and the user guide says what the rolloff is for. Shure explains that any cardioid mic boosts bass by 6 to 10 dB below 100 Hz when the source is about 6 mm away, and the SM58 deliberately rolls the bass off to keep that from turning boomy when a singer eats the mic. The SM57 is listed down to 40 Hz instead of 50 Hz and sits closer to your mouth at the same grille contact, so the bass build-up at close range starts sooner.

Top end. The SM57's slightly higher output above 5 kHz falls right where consonants, "s" sounds and the bite of a voice live. On a dark or soft voice that can read as extra clarity. On a voice that is already sharp, or on a cheap headset you monitor with, the same lift makes sibilance more obvious.

Plosives. This is the practical one. A "p" or "b" throws a burst of air straight at the capsule. The SM58's ball grille and built-in pop filter put both distance and a filter between your lips and the diaphragm. The SM57 has neither, which is why it is the mic that thumps on calls.

Shure's conclusion is careful: the SM57's extra proximity effect and upper boost "can sometimes also bolster certain voices", and the right answer comes from experimenting. That is honest, and it also tells you the default: a mic built for voices is the better blind buy for a voice.

Using an SM57 for vocals: when it makes sense

"SM57 for vocals" is a common search for a reason. Plenty of recordings have used it on singers, and it is a perfectly usable vocal mic once you deal with its one weakness.

It makes sense if:

  • You record more than your voice. A guitar amp, a snare, a practice room. The SM57 is designed for that, its small head fits close to a speaker cone, and one mic covering both jobs saves $109.
  • Your voice is soft or dark and you want a little more edge at the top without reaching for EQ.
  • You mount it on a stand or arm and keep a steady distance, so the stronger proximity effect stays predictable.

If you go this way, budget for Shure's A2WS locking windscreen, a foam ball made for the SM57 to cut breath and wind noise (its recommended price in the EU is €25). Without it, speak slightly across the mic instead of straight into it, the same trick the SM58 guide recommends for fewer "s" sounds: 20 to 60 cm away and a little to one side. At 20 cm, though, a dynamic mic delivers far less level, and level is the real problem at home.

Shure SM58 for podcasts, streaming and calls at home

The SM58 was built as a handheld stage mic, and it carries some features that do nothing for you at a desk: a pneumatic shock mount against handling noise, and a steel mesh grille that Shure says is designed to dent, protecting the mic inside. On an arm in a spare room, none of that is needed. What does help at home is the built-in pop filter and the bass roll-off, both aimed at someone talking a few centimetres from the mic.

The SM58 user guide gives three distances:

  • Under 15 cm, or touching the grille: fullest sound, most bass, maximum isolation from other sounds in the room.
  • 15 to 60 cm, just above nose height: more natural, less bass.
  • 20 to 60 cm, off to one side: natural, less bass and fewer "s" sounds.

For podcasting and streaming at home, the first zone is where a dynamic mic earns its reputation. It works because level falls by about 6 dB every time you double the distance, while your keyboard and the room's reflections stay where they are. Move from 5 cm to 10 cm and your voice drops about 6 dB relative to everything else; move to 20 cm and it has lost about 12. That is why people who buy an SM58 for its noise rejection and then put it 40 cm away on a desk stand are disappointed: at that distance the mic is hearing a lot of room.

The cost of the close zone is visual and physical. On a video call the mic will be in frame, so a low-profile boom arm that comes in from the side or below usually looks better than a desk stand in front of your face. And since the SM58 is a handheld mic, a cheap arm can sag under its 330 g if the spring is tuned for lighter mics.

What you need to connect an SM58 or SM57 to a Mac

Both mics have a three-pin XLR output and nothing else. There is no USB version of either one, so you need a box that contains a microphone preamp and a converter. The chain looks like this:

SM58 / SM57  →  XLR cable  →  preamp + converter  →  USB-C  →  Mac
                               (interface or XLR-to-USB adapter)

Phantom power (48 V): not needed, leave it off
Gain needed at 7 to 8 cm from the mouth: about 57 dB
Mac input: System Settings > Sound > Input > choose the device

Where does "about 57 dB" come from? Shure's support team gives typical speech as about 84 dB SPL at 3 inches (about 7.6 cm) and says the SM7B, at -59 dBV/Pa, needs at least 60 dB of gain at that level. The SM58 and SM57 are both -56 dBV/Pa, 3 dB more output than the SM7B, so the same arithmetic lands at about 57 dB. Back off to 15 cm and you need about 6 dB more.

That number matters because many small interfaces stop around it. A few options, with prices as of October 2026:

OptionMax gainPrice (US)What to expect with an SM58
Shure MVX2U Gen 2 (XLR-to-USB-C adapter)+60 dB$139Plugs into the mic, one cable to the Mac, about 3 dB of headroom over the target
Focusrite Scarlett Solo 4th Gen57 dB$169.99Right at the top of its range for close speech
Focusrite Scarlett 2i2 4th Gen69 dB$239.99Comfortable, with room to spare
Any interface + Cloudlifter CL-1+25 dB on top$129 for the boosterFixes an interface that runs out of gain

The difference between the Solo and the 2i2 is covered in Focusrite Scarlett Solo or 2i2, and the wider question of adapters is in can you plug an XLR mic into a Mac with a USB adapter. If you already own an interface and the meter barely moves, an inline booster is the fix; whether you need a Cloudlifter or FetHead covers when that is money well spent.

Two traps people hit:

  • Turning on 48 V phantom power "just in case". A dynamic mic does not use it. Leave it off; see what phantom power is and which mics need it.
  • Raising the Mac's input slider instead of the preamp gain. The slider in System Settings scales a signal that has already been converted. If the preamp is too low, the noise comes up with your voice. Set gain on the interface first, then use the slider for fine trim.

Which SM58 to buy: LC, LCE, S, SE and Beta 58A

Shop listings use suffix letters that look like different microphones. They are not.

  • SM58-LC: the standard mic, no switch, no cable. This is the SKU on Shure's US store.
  • SM58-LCE: the same switchless mic under the label used in European shops. Same capsule, same specs.
  • SM58S / SM58SE: the version with an on/off switch on the body, per Shure's user guide. Handy on a stage, mostly irrelevant at a desk where you mute in software.
  • Cable or no cable: Shure's store sells the SM58 with or without an XLR-to-XLR cable. You will need an XLR cable either way, so check before you order.
  • Beta 58A ($179 on shure.com US): a different mic. Shure describes it as having a tighter supercardioid pattern, hotter output, extended response and less handling noise. The hotter output means a little less gain needed. A supercardioid also picks up a little from directly behind, where a cardioid is deafest, so it suits a desk best when nothing noisy sits behind the mic.

One more thing about where you buy. Fakes of both mics circulate on the second-hand market, common enough that the UK dealer Sine-Post published a guide to spotting fake SM57s and SM58s. A "new" SM58 well under the usual price from an unknown seller deserves suspicion.

Shure SM58 vs SM7B

The SM7B is the mic people actually picture on a podcast desk, and the price gap is large: $439 against $109 on Shure's US store as of October 2026.

SM58SM7B
Sensitivity-56 dBV/Pa-59 dBV/Pa
Gain for speech at about 7.6 cmabout 57 dB (derived above)at least 60 dB (Shure)
Pop protectionBall grille + filterTwo windscreens included
Tone controlsNoneBass roll-off and presence switches
MountingHandheld, stand clipBracket for arm or stand

The SM7B needs 3 dB more gain than the SM58, which is exactly why the Scarlett Solo, topping out at 57 dB, falls short for it. In return it brings a broadcast-style mounting bracket, tone switches and more protection against breath. Whether that is worth $330 more for a home setup is a separate question, answered in is the Shure SM7B worth it for a home setup. For calls and streams, the SM58 plus a decent arm covers most of the job at a quarter of the price.

What neither mic will fix

The SM57 vs SM58 debate usually skips this part. Once you are close to either mic, the capsule is rarely what holds your sound back. The usual culprits are:

  • Distance drifts. You lean back during a long call, the level drops 6 to 12 dB, and the room comes up.
  • Gain set once, wrong. Too low and the call app pumps up your voice along with the noise; too high and loud laughs clip.
  • The room. A dynamic mic rejects distant reflections better than a condenser, but a bare room still leaks into a mic 15 cm away.
  • Tone the mic was not built for. The SM58's bass roll-off suits a singer pressed against the grille. Talking from 10 cm, some voices come across thinner than they do in person.

Free tools cover part of this. Zoom, Discord and OBS all have their own noise suppression and filters, and on a Mac you can adjust the input level in System Settings. The catch is that each app processes on its own terms, so your voice can differ from Zoom to Telegram to OBS, and none of them looks at your specific mic.

This is where TunedMic fits, and only if you are on a Mac. It adds a virtual microphone called TunedMic that any app can select. Your SM58 or SM57 stays plugged into the interface as usual; TunedMic takes its signal, processes it on the Mac in real time, and Zoom, Meet, Discord, OBS or Telegram hear the result. Setup is a one-minute Sound Check: you read a short passage aloud, and TunedMic takes more than 30 measurements of your voice, your mic and your room. Nine profiles in three families (Narrator, Creator, Vocal) are built from that check, not picked from stock presets. Optional manual controls cover noise, room echo, clarity, loudness and a 12-band equaliser, which is where you would soften the SM58's top end or tame the SM57's lift above 5 kHz.

The limits, plainly: TunedMic needs a Mac with Apple silicon (M1 or newer) and macOS 14 or later. There is no Windows version and no Intel support. It will not make an SM58 sound like an SM7B, and it does not remove every noise. The 38-second video on the home page shows how the setup works, not how a Shure sounds, so the real test is your own SM58 or SM57 during the trial. There is a free 7-day trial that starts at first launch, needs no card or account and includes every feature; after that it is $19 once, and payments are final.

A setup checklist with numbers

Mic:        SM58 for voice only; SM57 + A2WS foam if it also records instruments
Distance:   5 to 10 cm, slightly off-axis if "s" sounds are sharp
Mount:      boom arm that holds 330 g, coming in from the side
Preamp:     at least 60 dB of gain (MVX2U Gen 2, Scarlett 2i2), or 57 dB + booster
Phantom:    OFF
Gain:       loud laughs peak around -12 to -6 dBFS on the interface meter
Mac:        System Settings > Sound > Input > your interface
Apps:       pick the same input everywhere (or the TunedMic virtual mic)

Your next step

If you have not bought yet: order the SM58, an XLR cable and a preamp with at least 60 dB of gain, and put the money you might have spent on an SM7B toward a proper arm. If you already own either mic and it sounds thin, quiet or roomy on calls, first move it to 5 to 10 cm and check your gain against the numbers above. If it still falls short on your Mac, run Sound Check with your own mic during the free 7-day trial and, with headphones on, flip between the raw and tuned sound on your own voice. The license is on the pricing page if you decide to keep it.

Keep reading